Reply to Re: tiles request
If you don't have an account, just leave the password field blank.
How good a file is is what you rate, but if it's easy to make it's probably not really useful since you can easily make it yourself. That's a very valid consideration if you ask me.
If something deserves a 10 it must be very special indeed, if you give something a 10 it means that you probably don't think anything better will come along in the foreseeable future. For graphics I think the standard is a bit of to the high side. A 6 is a good score for a normal, decent graphicspack without anyting special(the same is true for DMODs I think). But if you look at the ratings given to graphicpacks it's rare to find a rating below 7. which is a high score, especially when considering that most graphicpacks have never been used in any DMOD.
But it's hard to judge, there really isn't a standard, and when I look at my own (short) list of DMODs I've reviewed I think I've used mixed standards too. It's just really hard to decide what is a good standard since everybody thinks different about it. Sometimes the most critical review gives the highest scores...
If something deserves a 10 it must be very special indeed, if you give something a 10 it means that you probably don't think anything better will come along in the foreseeable future. For graphics I think the standard is a bit of to the high side. A 6 is a good score for a normal, decent graphicspack without anyting special(the same is true for DMODs I think). But if you look at the ratings given to graphicpacks it's rare to find a rating below 7. which is a high score, especially when considering that most graphicpacks have never been used in any DMOD.
But it's hard to judge, there really isn't a standard, and when I look at my own (short) list of DMODs I've reviewed I think I've used mixed standards too. It's just really hard to decide what is a good standard since everybody thinks different about it. Sometimes the most critical review gives the highest scores...
