The Dink Network

Reply to Re: fantasy book

If you don't have an account, just leave the password field blank.
Username:
Password:
Subject:
Antispam: Enter Dink Smallwood's last name (surname) below.
Formatting: :) :( ;( :P ;) :D >( : :s :O evil cat blood
Bold font Italic font hyperlink Code tags
Message:
 
 
April 28th 2008, 12:40 PM
maidenb.gif
Sharp
Peasant She/Her Finland
 
Well actually, I didn't find anything wrong with the criticism. He found the piece lacking in action (and even pointed out how to fix this: "start with some action or romance."). Sounds constructive enough. It was a piece of advice, anyway.

What I don't see is why he should write something better if he "doesn't want to be constructive". It has nothing to do with criticizing? I like my right to criticize things I'm not able to make myself.. like, poetry, or commercial computer software. Or stuff.