Reply to Re: stuck on secret island in prophecy of the ancients
If you don't have an account, just leave the password field blank.
Try to talk to the boatman from all angles and places... There are two likely explanations to why you can't talk to him; he's placed weirdly so you can't "reach" him well by talking, or there's a bug. In the latter case, the best option to fix this would be to cheat your way back to the mainland.